In Life is a Miracle, Wendell Berry writes:
“We humans cannot live without acting; we have to act. Moreover, we have to act on the basis of what we know, and what we know is incomplete. What we have come to know so far is demonstrably incomplete, since we keep on learning more, and there seems little reason to think that our knowledge will become significantly more complete. The mystery surrounding our life probably is not significantly reducible. And so the question of how to act in ignorance is paramount.”
“Our history enables us to suppose that it may be all right to act on the basis of incomplete knowledge if our culture has an effective way of telling us that our knowledge is incomplete, and also of telling us how to act in our state of ignorance. We may go so far as to say that it is all right to act on the basis of sure knowledge, since our studies and our experience have given us knowledge that seems to be pretty sure. But apparently it is dangerous to act on the assumption that sure knowledge is complete knowledge—or on the assumption that our knowledge will increase fast enough to outrace the bad consequences of the arrogant use of incomplete knowledge. To trust ‘progress’ or our putative ‘genius’ to solve all the problems that we cause is worse than bad science; it is bad religion.”
Yet we plunge headlong into doing whatever seems right, certain that better (future) minds will do it better than us…right?

1 response so far ↓
1 Genetically Modified Crops Produce Less, Not More // Apr 22, 2008 at 8:13 am
[…] over a year ago, I called this “acting in ignorance.” For me, it’s more than just being wary of technology or science; it’s being […]
Leave a Comment